AV俱乐部

The work it takes to create a better, more equitable world is never complete. AV俱乐部 Legal Aid Service (DLAS) is celebrating 50 years of that dedication and hard work. Work that is just as important, just as relevant today as it was 50 years ago. Perhaps, some might argue, even more so.

If there is a theme that runs through the kinds of stories that are told about DLAS, it is this: Every person who has spent time there as a client, as a staff member, or as a student, believes that there is always something鈥攁nd someone鈥攅lse to keep fighting for.

But to say that DLAS is only about the fight is far from the whole story. DLAS balances optimism with realism. Tenacity with acceptance. All in service to making progress that is tangible and real, whether that serves a single person or thousands of people fighting an unjust system.

After educating and shaping over 2000 students, this is a moment to reflect and celebrate in the history of DLAS. It is also a moment to look to the future, and the next 50 years of change that its staff, students, clients, and community will create in the lives of people here in Nova Scotia and across the country.

This is a story that鈥檚 far from over. But in its telling, we can recognize what鈥檚 already been achieved and strengthen the resolve of those who will shape the stories to come.

The early days of the Clinic

In the summer of 1970, the Halifax Neighbourhood Centre alongside students from the law school at AV俱乐部 were spending their days鈥攁nd likely evenings鈥攊nside, away from summer鈥檚 freedoms, doing something new.

They were creating what would become the AV俱乐部 Legal Aid Service (the Clinic, as it鈥檚 often called) because they felt and heard what the community in the North End of Halifax needed. The community was crying out for access to justice for those experiencing barriers to legal services. And AV俱乐部鈥檚 law students believed they could do something about it.听

鈥淭he real movers and shakers behind the establishment of the Clinic were students from the law school,鈥� says Dick Evans, a former Clinic director, who was instrumental in shaping the vision and structure of DLAS for its future. When the Clinic was founded, by and for its community, it became the first university-based clinical law program in Canada. From its inception, and thanks to the dedication of its many champions, the Clinic鈥檚 mission has always been clear:

• To provide legal aid services for persons who otherwise would not be able to obtain legal advice or assistance.
• To conduct research, provide information, make recommendations and engage in programs relating to legal aid and law reform in the province of Nova Scotia.
• To provide an educational experience in the solution of legal problems for students enrolled in the Faculty of Law of AV俱乐部 who participate in the work of the Service (the Clinic).

The early days of the Clinic were undeniably different from today. For instance, Evans remembers that just before he joined the Clinic, there was not an existing director in place and the students were rather short on supervision. 鈥淲hen I arrived in June of 1975, Sarah Mackenzie, a newly called lawyer and recent hire was holding down the fort, along with just five summer students.鈥� Like every new organization, the early DLAS team had to not just think outside the box, but sometimes do things in a less-than-traditional fashion.

Rollie Thompson (鈥�78) can attest to this. Thompson is currently a member of the Board of Trustees. He鈥檚 acted as both the Clinic board鈥檚 chair and vice-chair, and as a student in 1977-78, he sat on the board as a student member. And, most importantly, he was the Clinic鈥檚 executive director from 1982-1985 and reprised this role from 1991-94 alongside Evans.

鈥淓ven when I wasn鈥檛 actively at the Clinic, I was still involved,鈥� Thompson says. 鈥淚鈥檇 take cases, consult with lawyers, and stay in touch with clients.鈥� So to say he is intrinsically woven into the fabric of the Clinic may be an understatement.

He remembers his first case at the Clinic鈥攁 two-day custody trial. 鈥淚 had no idea what I was doing,鈥� Thompson laughs. 鈥淏ut the learning experience for students has improved dramatically over the years and so has the standard of practice. The students are the ones who make it possible for DLAS to handle its incredible caseload.鈥�

Donna Franey (鈥�86) the Executive Director of DLAS for the past 25 years, remembers the organized chaos of the Clinic鈥檚 early days as well. 鈥淥ne of the students was involved in a family case and the judge ended up ordering the client鈥檚 belongings to be delivered to DLAS,鈥� remembers Franey. 鈥淪ometimes the Clinic is the only way to make something work for someone who needs help. It can be a fly-by-the-seat-of-your-pants experience.鈥�

听

Shaping law students

Within this unique atmosphere, the principles that were shaping the Clinic鈥檚 culture, were clear and true: to provide access to justice, enact important law reform, and to educate and develop young lawyers.

This early clarity brought with it remarkable drive and dedication to the community from everyone at the Clinic. In 1976, Evans and Doug Kane, a community development worker, helped the Clinic evolve from an advisory board to include nine community representatives. An important change ensuring that the perspective of the people the Clinic serves remains at the heart of its mission, its work, and the students it teaches.

Lori McCurdy (鈥�94) says that what鈥檚 special about the Clinic is the ability for students to create change. 鈥淚t goes beyond the academic,鈥� she says. 鈥淲e were exposed to various experiences of communities we might not otherwise have been aware of and learned that we could do something to contribute to changing those experiences - improving those experiences.鈥�

鈥淥ne thing that鈥檚 remained consistent is the drive from students and staff to help clients,鈥� Thompson says. 鈥淢otivation has never been an issue. Everyone wants to do right by their clients.鈥�

Franey agrees. 鈥淭he students work so hard and form such a bond with the clients. It鈥檚 human nature for the more established team to worry about new students coming in鈥攖hat they won鈥檛 treat the clients as well as the past students did. But that鈥檚 never the case. Students always see that people are people, no matter where or who they are. And every person deserves to be treated with the same dignity.鈥�

The Clinic鈥檚 impact on its students can鈥檛 be understated. Not only because of the practical experience it provides, but because of the values and ideals it imparts.

And powerful values stick.

Today, the true picture of those who study law is significantly more diverse and representative of the society in which we live. The people studying law come with more varied and unique backgrounds, and may come with an understanding and experience that aligns with clients at the Clinic too.

This wasn鈥檛 always the case. Over the years the Clinic opened many young eyes to the reality and truth of Nova Scotian communities, and the injustice, poverty, and inequality that still exist. 鈥淢any law students that come from backgrounds of privilege are suddenly immersed in poverty law,鈥� says Nova Scotia Supreme Court Justice John Bodurtha (鈥�95). 鈥淲e are privileged to be learning the law and it teaches students the opportunities a law degree presents to advance the causes of marginalized communities.鈥�

It is clear that an experience at the Clinic teaches so much more than the law. It clarifies what is worth fighting for. It imparts courage and confidence. It highlights the inevitability of loss. And it demonstrates, every day, the power when people come together.

The one and the many听

The stories that have shaped the Clinic are often singular. A story of one client, one case, one relationship. They are a memory or moment.

But the truth is that these individual stories represent so much more, and one of the Clinic鈥檚 many strengths has been its ability to be the bridge between the one and the many. For a small staff, the Clinic has brought successful cases to the Supreme Court of Canada on three separate occasions.

鈥淚t really is the little engine that could,鈥� says Justice Bodurtha. 鈥淪ome of the cases the Clinic has been involved in are remarkable and it deserves to be recognized and supported for these achievements.鈥�

Access to justice听

Rocky Jones (鈥�92) is a legend not only in Nova Scotia鈥檚 legal system, but in the social justice landscape as well. His legacy is exemplified in his work with Rodney Small, who was tried in Youth Court before Judge Corrine Sparks (鈥�79). His case centered around an interaction between Small and a police officer.

Though both he and Jones didn鈥檛 know it early on, Small鈥檚 case would end up representing so much more in Canadian law, connecting dots between racial bias, policing, justice, civil rights, judicial impartiality and more. While Judge Sparks鈥攏otably the first Black judge in Nova Scotia鈥攈ad found Small not guilty, the Crown鈥檚 reaction to the ruling led Jones and Small all the way to the Supreme Court of Canada. This experience fundamentally changed Small鈥檚 life, and ultimately, set legal precedents when it came to racial bias in policing across the country.

鈥淩ocky was the real deal, a lawyer who was a social advocate too,鈥� Small remembers. 鈥淲e had a real relationship, and it was bumpy sometimes because I was rough around the edges. But he had so much positive energy, so when I wanted to back away from the case, Rocky was strong for me.鈥�

Raised in Uniacke Square, Rodney is now the Director of ONE North End and part of Common Good Solutions, an organization in Atlantic Canada developing strategies to build equitable policies to improve the lives of poor and marginalized communities.

鈥淏ack then, I was ready to leave Nova Scotia,鈥� Small says. 鈥淚 was going down a dark path. But when I read the decision about my case on the front page of the newspaper, I knew it was my time, and that I needed to pull myself in a new direction.鈥�

Today, as a leader in his community, Small also focuses on sharing the history of his neighbourhood and bringing people together to create change. 鈥淎V俱乐部 Legal Aid is a pillar in this community. It gives space for real dialogue and is truly representative of the people it serves,鈥� he says. 鈥淚 was lucky to have a lawyer in my life who understood my situation. Who knew my community and was in my community.鈥�

Shawna Paris-Hoyte (鈥�94), Q.C. and 25-year veteran of DLAS as a staff lawyer, acknowledges just how meaningful this case was. 鈥淚t has had an enormous impact,鈥� she says. 鈥淚t gave the Supreme Court of Canada voice to the issue of race and bias. And twenty-three years later, our team continues this work today, giving voice to things like racial injustice in street checks and other social issues.鈥�

This is just one story鈥攐ne of many that represent the change and impact that DLAS has had. What can鈥檛 be denied: The Clinic鈥檚 ongoing legacy of ensuring the legal rights of underrepresented communities both in Nova Scotia and in Canadian law.

Law reform

Institutional power is slow and difficult to impact. It鈥檚 hard to criticize, dismantle, or move bureaucracy forward.

But AV俱乐部 Legal Aid Service has done it. Many times over.

Today, for instance, Nova Scotia has some of the best rules and regulations in the country governing credit, collections and disconnection by Nova Scotia Power, thanks to the tireless work of Thompson and former DLAS caseworker Jeanne Fay, among many others.

鈥淭here was a fundamental truth in the argument that we fought to have recognized,鈥� says Thompson. 鈥淚f the Utility and Review Board was going to give permission to raise rates, then regulations had to evolve too. There needs to be more protection for low-income communities, and eventually we came out with a set of rules and regulations that could continue to be improved.鈥�

Franey says that the Clinic works to prioritize more of these kinds of cases, digging down to systemic problems to create change. 鈥淲hen you see something time and time again, our team looks for the root of the issue,鈥� says Franey. 鈥淲hether it鈥檚 an adult protection matter, ensuring that the government puts the welfare of the person ahead of their own interests, or a human rights inquiry about whether disabled people are being unnecessarily institutionalized, removed from their communities and losing their autonomy, we are doing transformative work.鈥�

The teamwork that imbues everything DLAS does is also something Franey emphasizes. 鈥淲e have community legal workers, lawyers, and students out there working with people all the time,鈥� she says. 鈥淪o often the community comes to us and tells us where we need to focus attention so that we not only create meaningful law reform, but also contribute to tangible change in the community we serve.鈥�

Community impact听

Even when addressing broad change at the institutional level, the issues DLAS tackles are often ones of basic human survival, issues connected to poverty, health, shelter, human rights, discrimination and so many more.

Paris-Hoyte understands that fact on a fundamental level. 鈥淲e are, in many ways, the last stop for people whose everyday existence is threatened,鈥� she says. 鈥淥ur connection to the AV俱乐部 School of Social Work means we can work collaboratively to address bigger social issues鈥攚e help fuse law and social work together. And the gaps between these two things have the greatest impact on marginalized communities.鈥�

Perhaps the best example of this fusion is the Clinic鈥檚 contribution to Bryony House. In 1978, the Clinic helped create the first transition house in Nova Scotia providing emergency services for women affected by intimate partner abuse. And early in Bryony House鈥檚 history, two members of the DLAS team left the Clinic to work with Bryony House full-time.

鈥淭he Clinic began outreach sessions there once a month with residents,鈥� says Franey. 鈥淢any of these women had never had to find housing, or try to get income assistance, or deal with criminal law or peace bonds. Our team was learning along with the Transition House Association how best to protect people and what services they needed.鈥�

Paris-Hoyte believes you need these kinds of embedded relationships with the community to make a real difference. 鈥淎 lot of legal aid Clinics hire social workers,鈥� she says. 鈥淏ut DLAS has long-standing connections and a very diverse team when it comes to legal and life experience. And when your community legal workers have a background in social work, it adds a special lens to everything we work on.鈥�

Senator Kim Pate (LLB 鈥�84), who has spent four decades advocating on behalf of marginalized and victimized Canadians, agrees. 鈥淭he importance of having a social worker attached to the Clinic helped me see that we weren鈥檛 just looking at court cases, but we were looking at important public policy areas.鈥� Put simply, the Clinic builds bridges.

The Clinic鈥檚 resilience and tenacity also ensures that things get done.

A lasting legacy听

Whether it鈥檚 a scared client, a young student, or an overextended lawyer, those who enter the Clinic may enter feeling alone.

That feeling doesn鈥檛 last long.

The importance of the work, the dedication of the team, and the sense of making a difference all work together to create bonds that stand the test of time. Whether a lawyer has just started their law career or has been practicing for decades, the impact of the Clinic never leaves.

Katie Brady (JD 鈥�19) says that her Clinic experience helped her reconnect with why she wanted to study law in the first place. 鈥淚 wanted to help people,鈥� she says. 鈥淚 lost that clarity in law school and it was only after my legal aid experience that I regained that focus that allowed me to find the people in the stories I鈥檇 hear in class.鈥�

The connections between classroom theory and the real world also became clear to Dinyar Marzban (LLB 鈥�81), now a Q.C. and family law attorney in Vancouver, during his time at the Clinic. 鈥淥ne of my Clinic lawyers was Sarah Mackenzie,鈥� he remembers. 鈥淪he was always calm, always smiling, but really tough too. Once she sat with me for hours going through an affidavit, correcting tense, grammar, clarity of thought. I probably learned 75 percent of my drafting skills in that one session with her, from having an experienced lawyer go through a real affidavit with me.鈥�

Ellen Williams (JD 鈥�20) shares this perspective. 鈥淵ou don鈥檛 get the human component of law from textbooks,鈥� she says. 鈥淏eing able to communicate with someone in times of stress is a learned art, and you need to be their rock. The hands-on experience at the Clinic got me ready for the real world.鈥�

鈥淚t was fun too,鈥� says McCurdy. 鈥淵ou were with like-minded people doing meaningful work, applying legal principles鈥攕ometimes in creative ways鈥攁nd you always felt supported.鈥�

The richness of human experience is woven throughout the history of DLAS. Every person who has experienced it, used it, learned from it, brings some of its optimism and hope with them on their own journey.

A beacon of tomorrow听

The cases and people who will come next to AV俱乐部 Legal Aid Service are unknowable. But while the specifics might be cloudy, the principles shaping the Clinic鈥檚 future remain steadfast.

鈥淔or fifty years, DLAS has been providing an essential service to our community, making legal information and advice available to people who would not otherwise have that access. It has also given thousands of law students a great opportunity to apply their learning, acquire valuable lawyering skills, and gain an understanding of the challenges 鈥� and not only legal challenges - that are faced by so many people,鈥� says Schulich School of Law Dean Camille Cameron. 鈥淎s we look to the next 50 years, we are committed to continuing to support and champion the Clinic so that it can carry on this work, work that can make a big difference in the lives of clients, students, and the community.鈥�

The Clinic will teach. It will open eyes, reveal truth, build character, and push students and clients to be and do things they didn鈥檛 think they could. It will be generous with its knowledge, to individuals and to its community, sharing what it learns and bringing ideas and people together.

It will open the avenues to justice for those who have no other way and be a voice for those who need one. It will illuminate the patterns of injustice that should demand our attention and the legal changes we can make to improve our society and the lives of every citizen.

It will continue to serve the community that has nurtured it for the last 50 years. Amid all the wins and the losses, all the frustrations and the steps forward, DLAS will unite those striving for justice in all its forms. And, ultimately, it is a very special place in our community, representing the people of Nova Scotia who are fighting for a better world.