AV俱乐部

Susan Bryson holds AV俱乐部's Joan and Jack Chair in Autism Research. (Danny Abriel Photo)

She seemed to be everywhere. Last fall, actress Jenny McCarthy could be found on a host of American talk shows, including Larry King Live, The View and The Oprah Winfrey Show promoting her book Louder than Words: A Mother鈥檚 Journey in Healing Autism. During the Oprah appearance, she made several controversial claims, including the idea that vaccines had a role to play in causing her son鈥檚 autism. 鈥淭he nurse gave (Evan) the shot... and soon thereafter鈥攂oom鈥攖he soul鈥檚 gone from his eyes,鈥� she said.

Seen by millions of Oprah viewers, hers was a compelling story, presented passionately and articulately. But was she right? 鈥淚鈥檓 just a mom,鈥� she said, adding she received her degree from 鈥渢he University of Google.鈥�

Despite the lack of credible scientific evidence establishing a connection between vaccines and autism, debate rages on. The controversy seems to be everywhere, fuelled by celebrities, bloggers, websites and the mainstream media. With autism rates continuing to rise (estimated at one child in 166), now more than ever parents are finding themselves confused and doubtful about whether to vaccinate their children.

What should parents believe? Is there a connection between autism and vaccines?

鈥淲e don鈥檛 want to close our minds to further research and inquiry, but we really need to treat the vaccine-autism connection as highly speculative,鈥� says Susan Bryson, AV俱乐部鈥檚 Joan and Jack Craig Chair in Autism Research, and one of the world鈥檚 foremost autism experts.

鈥淲e should still ask questions and seek answers, but in the meantime, we need to follow paths that are evidence-based and make sense theoretically,鈥� she says. 鈥淓specially when we are considering what the priorities are for focusing our attention and money.鈥�

While experts say there is no reliable way to track the impact of the controversy on Canada鈥檚 vaccination rates, in other countries like Britain, MMR (measles, mumps and rubella) vaccination rates plummeted from 95 to 75 per cent (although that figure has begun to recover). The British outbreak of these diseases can be traced directly to one of the only studies that suggested a link between autism and vaccines. That study has since has been widely discredited, and retracted by most of its authors (see sidebar).

A quick Internet search uncovers dozens of articles, websites and discussion groups insisting the link between autism and vaccines exists. But scientific evidence establishing that link is much harder to come by.

Dr. Bryson notes the complexity of autism as a relatively new disorder (only on the books since the 1940s) may be a factor in the rise of some of the controversy. 鈥淭here is so much we still don鈥檛 know about autism. Wouldn鈥檛 it be lovely if we discovered there was just one protein missing in our DNA that caused the disorder, or something simple like that? All we can say is that there is nothing in the science that has been discovered so far that suggests the answer will be that easy.鈥�

In the meantime, she and her team continue to focus their efforts on early detection and intervention. She conducted a landmark epidemiological study of autism, the first of its kind for North America, right here in Nova Scotia in the 1980s. Since then, she and her researchers have studied 350 families for more than 10 years in a project she began at Sick Kids Hospital in Toronto.

That study has led to her current research on developing earlier autism detection and intervention for babies. She also designed and played a leadership role in implementing an early intervention treatment program for autistic children in Nova Scotia, and together with Dr. Isabel Smith, is tracking the results.

鈥淲e know that if we can get in earlier with a diagnosis, and focus on early intervention, we are better able to help the child,鈥� she says. 鈥淭he earlier the better.鈥� Currently, her team is identifying signs of autism in children between 12 and 18 months old. So far, these signs (including delayed or lost speech, lack of social smiling, fixating on certain objects, failing to respond when name is called and unusual responses to sensations) are all behavioral. No reliable physical test is yet available.

As for the continuing debate over vaccines and autism, she says the focus needs to shift from speculation to proven fact. 鈥淭here has been so much emphasis on the potential link between vaccines and autism, and not enough attention to the fact that diseases like measles can be fatal for children who are not immunized. That is a proven fact,鈥� she says.

鈥淚t鈥檚 a lot sexier and more interesting to talk about what we think is fact, than to talk about the things we don鈥檛 know. With autism, there is still so much we just don鈥檛 know.鈥�